Head to head ยท Protein Powder

Nancy's Yogurt Cottage Cheese vs Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey

Reddit prefers Nancy's Yogurt Cottage Cheese โ€” higher sentiment (53% vs 49% positive).

Nancy's Yogurt Cottage Cheese
#26 in Protein PowderReddit favorite

Nancy's

Nancy's Yogurt Cottage Cheese

$4.99

53

Pros

  • +Extra fermented
โ€œI use Nancyโ€™s and good culture. No idea about add ins but I know that Nancyโ€™s are โ€œextraโ€ fermentedโ€
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey
#1 in Protein Powder

Optimum Nutrition

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey

$68.99

49

Pros

  • +NSF certified
  • +delicious
  • +convenient
  • +high protein

Cons

  • โˆ’expensive
  • โˆ’inaccurate protein content
  • โˆ’tastes bad
  • โˆ’nasty taste
โ€œI personally like the taste of the optimum nutrition betterโ€
r/Costco