Head to head ยท Espresso Machines

Rancilio Silvia vs Breville Barista Express BES870XL

Reddit prefers Rancilio Silvia โ€” higher sentiment (100% vs 49% positive).

Rancilio Silvia
#17 in Espresso MachinesReddit favorite

Rancilio

Rancilio Silvia

$995.00

100

Pros

  • +Valuable even when old/broken
  • +Can be refurbished and sold for profit
  • +Satisfying enough not to upgrade
  • +Can make coffee as good as much more expensive machines (e.g., la marzocco linea mini) with skill

Cons

  • โˆ’May require minor repairs (e.g., new portafilter)
  • โˆ’Requires patience and know-how
  • โˆ’Needs mods (pids, 9 bar springs) to meet 'good machine' criteria
โ€œI found a Rancilio Silvia on the side of the road a couple of years ago. Like yours, I needed to buy a portafilter. $30 later, and after a little cleaning, I flipped it on eBay for $650.โ€
Breville Barista Express BES870XL
#2 in Espresso Machines

Sage

Breville Barista Express BES870XL

$679.99

49

Pros

  • +durable
  • +convenient
  • +good price
  • +reliable

Cons

  • โˆ’expensive
  • โˆ’more maintenance
  • โˆ’built-in grinder
  • โˆ’Poor durability
โ€œI picked up a $300 espresso DeLonghi at Savers a couple months back. It only cost $25 and I bought some cleaner for it. Good as new!โ€
r/Anticonsumption