Head to head ยท Hiking Boots

Altra Lone Peak 9 Hiking Shoe vs Thorogood 6" Moc-Toe Boot

Both products have identical sentiment scores on Reddit.

Altra Lone Peak 9 Hiking Shoe
#12 in Hiking Boots

Altra

Altra Lone Peak 9 Hiking Shoe

$189.95

100

Pros

  • +Less likely to sprain an ankle in most terrain
  • +Do fine with microspikes (wp lp's)
  • +Better feel and mobility
  • +Better responsiveness over varied terrain

Cons

  • โˆ’Not going to support crampons
  • โˆ’Not reasonable in deep snow
  • โˆ’Minimalist cushioning
  • โˆ’Zero drop
โ€œHonestly, I'm more likely to sprain an ankle in my single mountaineering Lowas than my Altra Lone Peaks in most terrain. The WP LP's do fine with microspikes, for those spring, mid-elevation training โ€
Thorogood 6" Moc-Toe Boot
#8 in Hiking Boots

Thorogood

Thorogood 6" Moc-Toe Boot

$264.95

100

Pros

  • +Very comfortable
  • +Soles look good
  • +Leather and stitching held up well
  • +Justified the cost

Cons

  • โˆ’Feet can get sore by end of week if only one pair worn
  • โˆ’Not truly bifl
โ€œI still only wear these boots because they're so damn comfortable. ... the soles look good and the leather and stitching has held up well. I've easily gotten enough miles out of them to justify the coโ€