r/positive
“Siri, make it dark” is just so good when you’re snuggled in bed and the effort of physical interaction with a light is too much.
Apple HomePod 2nd Generation
Apple HomePod Smart Speaker 2nd Generation, Siri Speaker + Power Cable + Apple 1 Year Limited Warranty (Midnight)
By Apple
22mentions14%positive$369.99typical+5pros
About this product
The Apple HomePod 2nd Generation is a premium smart speaker priced at $369.99, designed for Apple's ecosystem. It primarily functions as a Siri-enabled device for smart home control and personal assistance, though its voice assistant receives significant criticism.
Best for: Apple users for basic smart home voice control.
Pros
- Voice control for smart home lighting
- Convenience of control from bed
- Adds items to lists via voice
- Integrates with calendar and weather
Cons
- Siri is widely considered useless and dumb
- Frustrating and ineffective Siri performance
- Siri is uncompetitive compared to other AI
- Apple's management failing on Siri development
- Siri can be frustrating in the car
Verdict
“Skip, as Redditors widely report Siri's poor performance makes it largely unhelpful.”
AI-generated summary based on Reddit discussions about Apple HomePod 2nd Generation. Last updated Apr 20, 2026.
What one Redditor said
““Siri, make it dark” is just so good when you’re snuggled in bed and the effort of physical interaction with a light is too much.”
Where Reddit talks about it
22 comments · 2 subreddits
r/apple0%
17 mentions↑ 1.0K
r/MacOS0%
4 mentions↑ 30
Reddit reviews
+ 1~ 4− 17
r/MacOSnegative6
Great. Now Siri will be even *less* useful to me (while Google's AI is better than *some*, that "some" includes Copilot, which currently is at the, "Less useful than Clippy was" level of uselessness f
r/MacOSnegative18
How on earth could Siri be less useful for you given its current state? Gemini is far from being my preferred LLM… but it’s not *bad*. Not good but my god Siri is useless.
r/MacOSnegative4
This is a typical example of apples management falling completely. This goes to show how apple is becoming uncompetitive in future key business areas. They had 10 years time to create a better Siri. A
r/MacOSnegative2
Siri cannot be anymore dumb than it already is. Anything is better than what currently we have.
r/applenegative21
Yeah, it’s over, lmao. I was often adamant on here about believing it would come out in time, but I also said if it was delayed, I would lose hope. Well now it’s likely delayed. I don’t think it comes
r/applenegative178
Siri is so useless in the car that she actually promotes texting and driving. Apple really needs to get this together
r/applenegative49
I rarely get as frustrated as I do trying to use Siri in the car
r/applenegative4
I appreciate having a digital assistant that pushes back on my demands for everything I want at a moments notice. Chat GPT is such a suck up pushover. Siri is like a Czech bureaucrat during the war.
r/appleneutral154
Archived link: https://archive.ph/kzH0R ✨ Apple Intelligence summary: Apple’s iOS 26.4 Siri update has encountered issues during testing, potentially delaying the release of new features until iOS 26
r/applenegative140
At this point we’re gonna get GTA6 before we get new Siri
r/applenegative141
The excerpt that was taken down from the [9to5Mac reporting](https://9to5mac.com/2026/02/11/apple-reportedly-pushing-back-gemini-powered-siri-features-beyond-ios-26-4/) of this Bloomberg article: *Af
r/applenegative26
GTA 6 will be out before a fully working Siri 🧐
r/applenegative102
I’m officially convinced Siri was built on an ancient Indian burial ground.
r/applenegative75
here we go again! I suspect they just cant reliably get past prompt injection attacks. App Intents Siri is going the way of AirPower, an overly ambitious self own Edit: apparently it’s just too
Showing 15 of 22 reviews
✨ AI advisor
Still deciding? Ask Lava.
Describe your use case — Lava will tell you if this is the right pick, or recommend an alternative with cited Reddit sources.
Head-to-head
Apple HomePod 2nd Generation vs alternatives
How it stacks up against the top-ranked alternatives in the same category.
Frequently asked
Apple HomePod 2nd Generation: What people ask
Is the HomePod 2nd Generation worth buying?
Redditors largely agree it is not worth it due to Siri's poor performance. With 77% negative sentiment, many find Siri frustrating and unhelpful, describing it as useless.
Who is the HomePod 2nd Generation best for?
It is primarily for Apple users who want basic voice control for smart home functions, like lighting, and are tolerant of Siri's significant limitations. The convenience of controlling lights from bed is one of the few positive mentions.
What are the biggest complaints about the HomePod 2nd Generation?
The most significant complaint is Siri's severe lack of intelligence and functionality. Users describe Siri as useless, dumb, and frustrating, especially compared to other AI assistants like Google's or Gemini.
How do users describe Siri's intelligence on the HomePod?
Many Redditors describe Siri as 'useless' and 'dumb,' with some noting it's less helpful than Clippy. There's widespread frustration with its current capabilities, and some compare it to a 'Czech bureaucrat'.
Is Siri's performance a common issue?
Yes, Siri's poor performance is a consistent complaint, with 77% negative sentiment. Users frequently express frustration, particularly with its unreliability in cars, where it's seen as promoting dangerous behavior.
Related